Bunnahabhain is the self-described "gentle" whisky of Islay, so the peated Toiteach (meaning smoky) is a big departure for the distillery. The label intimates a light peat by inquiring: "What if a touch of smoke from our peated malted barley was introduced in the distillation process?"
The result is no mere touch of smoke but a flat out peat monster. Its not quite on the same level as the big Islay houses but is just a step below, about on par with Jura Prophecy. Blind-folded, I would have guessed this is a Jura based on the peat style as well, which is buttery. Unlike Prophecy though, Toiteach tastes pretty young with a basic sweet maltiness and a slight vegetal tinge on the palate. The finish turns drier and ashy. An enjoyable, straightforward dram, but not particularly engaging beyond the peat. 83 points (B-).
Other Bunnahabhain reviews: